Quora vs Yahoo Answers: Which Q&A Site is Better for Your Business?
Graph: Yahoo Answers and Quora compared on Google Trends for Websites (plus Twitter and Tumblr for a better perspective)
Many people ask questions on the Web, especially on search engines like Google but also on social media.
Even in cases where they don’t ask a question containing a question mark most queries are indeed questions as well, it’s just that people don’t enter the whole sentence in the Google search box.
Hype as hype can
When you search for [best smartphone] you are most probably asking “what is the best smartphone”. Even a search for smartphone itself implies that you are looking for the best or at least most popular smartphone.
We witnessed a frenzy on social media about Quora and the uber-hypebeasts Techcrunch and Robert Scoble are heavily promoting it. Pundits proclaim the next Twitter etc.
People have already written why such a hype is generally a bad idea and in the case of Quora particularly. At the end of the day Quora has to compete with the exiting elephtan in the room, Yahoo Answers.
You don’t have to be an expert to use Yahoo Answers
I’ve been on Quora for a few days now and have tested it so to say. Still there is Yahoo Answers, the number one Q&A site out there, the elephant in the room you have to beat to become the next big thing. Otherwise you’re just an also ran.
I’m not a Yahoo Answers expert but I have advised small business owners to participate there in the past. Why?
Let me tell you again pointing out the reasons why. As Quora is so popular among early adopters now I’d like to compare them with Quora. Does Quora have the same or other advantages?
Who uses the site?
Q: Elite. Tech pundits, entrepreneurs, early adopters, bloggers, marketers, social media mavens.
YA: Everybody. John Doe and his wife and even kids.
Who is your audience?
Are you selling high quality services and goods for professionals and other businesses? Use Quora.
Are you selling large numbers of products or local services to average people? Use Yahoo Answers.
Who are you?
Are you an accomplished expert with lots of time? Use Quora. Otherwise you don’t have a chance to stand out. For instance every question about SEO gets answered by renowned SEO expert Rand Fishkin of Moz. In other areas there are sometimes dozens or even hundreds of answers provided by highly skilled professionals.
There is no room for you in case you aren’t a leader already.
Although I’m pretty known in SEO circles I can’t compete with Rand who has a whole team of people working for him. He has the time to answer questions for free while others do the paid work for him. I don’t. Do you?
Are you the average business owner or freelancer like I am? Use Yahoo Answers. The answers are mostly so low quality that you can easily stand out. Real people aka potential clients read your advice and click your links. Of course you have to say more than “my SEO company is the best” but even some people get away with that low quality approach. You can perform better than that.
Are you after a good rep, authority and trust? Use Quora. Here you can build a reputation for yourself competing with the best of the best. You have to spend a few hours a day on it but it’s a long time investment. Then one day you can show that most people consider your answers and expertise to be worth it. Then you can earn money with it.
Are you after traffic, leads or even sales? Do you need to earn money right now? Don’t have the time to compete for days, weeks or months without getting something in return? Use Yahoo Answers.
Here people are asking for things they need right now. They would pay for it. You don’t need to be the best expert on something as long as your answer makes sense.
Can you keep up with all the questions?
I could ask questions like these for a while but I don’t have the time. Also my impression is that I can’t cope with Quora.
The pace questions get asked, answered, liked etc. is too fast on Quora.
I’m spending most of my social media time on Twitter and I won’t build a new power profile from zero. Also there are other sites to consider joining which actually don’t cost so much time investment. Prismatic might actually save you time.
Btw. I even rejoined Yahoo to test Yahoo Answers again as I lost my two older accounts from years ago. Maybe I start using Yahoo Answers regularly again. Judging from the replies to the SEO questions I could easily stand out in a positive way. Also Rand isn’t there.
You can follow me on both Q&A sites, Yahoo Answers and Quora if you like but as I said I’m mainly on Twitter.
[…] Quora vs Yahoo Answers: Which Q&A Site is Better for Your Business? (seo2.0.onreact.com) […]
Quora vs Yahoo Answers: Which Q&A Site is Better for Your Business?…
SNIP – Many people ask questions on the Web, especially on search engines like Google but also on social media. Even in cases where they don’t ask a question containing a question mark most queries ……
I’m so glad I came across your article because I was recently looking into Quora. Considering the points you’ve made here, it seems very difficult, though not impossible, to decipher yourself from the “big players” within the SEO industry. Considering I too run an SEO agency, maybe targeting questions specific to a service you offer could help you stand out. I’m thinking about taking this approach on Quora as a test.
As for Yahoo Answers, there are tons of questions by thousands of people that could be easily answered by even the most basic SEO. Since there are tons of opportunities through Yahoo Answers, it gives you plenty of chances to nab a new lead/client.
I have to look into both properties a little more, but with the right time and effort it could pay off in the long run. Just my thoughts =)
I agree with David. Great break down and insight into how a new business owner might want to spend their valuable time building a reputation. I know where I am headed after reading this :) !
Thanks Tad!
Hey David: Thank you for your insights. Good luck at Quora, I think Yahoo Answers is a better place to stick out though. Only experts read Quora now. The people are on YA.
Mike: Great. Where are you headed though? Tell me. See you there!
[…] Quora vs Yahoo Answers: Which Q&A Site is Better for Your Business? – On React […]
Great stuff. You have presented the topic in very simplified manner. I have no doubt that Yahoo Q&A is best suited for small business enterprises. On Yahoo Q&A, we can find and interact with individuals and businesses in any given sector or level of expertise. I agree with you that we must understand who our target audience is and act accordingly.
I think this is great advice. I think I will get used to Yahoo answers first. I provide high quality cleaning services so I may need to switch over to Quora. Thanks again.
I started using Quora about a week ago. Or I should say I registered. After reading this I went back and got more involved and so far I like it.
Maybe it is just the UX, but it seems to promote discussion a little more than YA. I dunno, maybe it is just me.
I have already connected with a couple of like-minded SEO people so that is pretty cool in my opinion.
I have dabbled in and had some good experiences with Yahoo Answers, too. But YA seems to be full of link builders with bogus questions: “what is best for SEOing my website?” which usually yields the answer: “Please to visit my site (insert URL) for best all helping with (insert issue here). It is number one website”.
To be fair though, that may be because I mostly look at SEO and internet marketing related questions.
[…] * Quora vs Yahoo Answers: Which Q&A; Site is Better for Your Business? […]
[…] SEO 2.0 | Quora vs Yahoo Answers: Which Q&A Site is Better for Your Business? […]
I recently started using Quora and the quality simply trumps Yahoo Answers entirely. The level of questions being asked are actually fun and worthwhile to answer.
Brilliant analysis. Thanks!
I tried both. I simply dislike YA, though Askville is ok. My favorite user experience is definitely on Q, though that is ultimately irrelevant when considering SEO benefits (except for quality of life during the process… hehe).
BTW, I suspect that Quora will earn a special place in Google’s SERPs as the years go by – due to the higher quality of answers on Q and the fact that Y!A is owned by G’s competitor.
Do you see these sites as a link building opportunity also. Because most of the Q&A sites are nofollow.
If answers yahoo is do-follow it should be the best.
I have just started to use Quora. I must say I like the quality. It is more of a challenge, I guess. But one has to be careful not to spend too much time on a question. Why not do a bit of both, depending on the time you have available?